Peppermint Mocha Cheesecake Recipe

This peppermint mocha cheesecake is a bold, wintry dessert that brings together the deep flavor of mocha cheesecake with the clean coolness of peppermint.

You’ll get a chocolate cookie crust, a rich espresso-laced filling, and a silky chocolate ganache. The topping? Whipped cream swirls and crushed peppermint for crunch and color. It’s a dessert made for the holiday table.

You’ll learn exactly how to build this Christmas mint cheesecake from crust to garnish. The recipe is structured, the flavors are balanced, and there’s nothing vague or overly sweet about it. This is a true holiday cheesecake for people who want to serve something bold.

The chocolate and peppermint pairing isn’t new. But blending them in a baked mocha cheesecake adds depth. It’s a dessert that holds its shape and doesn’t melt on the plate, which means it can sit proudly next to your pies, bars, and cookies. This version gives you structure, flavor, and that crowd-stopping finish.

What Makes This Holiday Cheesecake Worth Making

The crust starts with crushed chocolate cookies. I prefer using cookies without cream filling, like plain Oreos with the centers scraped out, because they give you a firmer base.

I’ve tested crusts with chocolate graham crackers too. Those work, but they bring a grainier texture and less chocolate flavor. When I use cookie crumbs, the base bakes cleanly and cuts neatly, which matters when you’re slicing for a crowd.

You’ll find a bit of sugar and salt in the mix. That pinch of salt tempers the sweetness and deepens the chocolate. The sugar helps bind the crust when baked. This part may seem simple, but it sets the tone for the entire cheesecake.

If you’re looking for another peppermint dessert with structure and flair, take a look at these Santa Hat Cheesecake Bites. They also lean into clean edges and bold flavor.

Building a Mocha Filling That Stays Creamy After Chilling

Cream cheese makes up the bulk of the filling. Use full-fat blocks, not whipped or tub-style cream cheese. Whipped versions break down under heat. You need density to support both the cocoa and the coffee.

Sour cream adds that slight tang and softness. It rounds out the sugar and keeps the cheesecake from leaning too sweet. I let mine sit out for 20 minutes before mixing to prevent clumps.

The cocoa powder brings depth, but it’s the espresso powder that wakes everything up. It sharpens the chocolate and gives this dessert its mocha identity. I’ve made versions with brewed coffee before. That added too much liquid and not enough flavor. Espresso powder dissolves completely and gives you full control.

You’ll notice both peppermint and vanilla extract here. The vanilla softens the edges of the mint. Straight peppermint can come across too sharp or medicinal, especially when chilled.

For another dessert that plays with warmth and winter notes, try the Eggnog Cheesecake Bars. They build flavor with similar care.

One Thought on Cocoa: Natural vs. Dutch-Processed

In my notes, I’ve tried this recipe with both types of cocoa powder. Natural cocoa gives a lighter, sharper chocolate flavor. Dutch-processed cocoa brings more richness and a darker color.

I lean toward Dutch-process for this specific recipe. It plays better with the espresso and peppermint. It also creates a cleaner, more dramatic color contrast under the whipped cream topping. That’s especially noticeable when slicing.

If you’ve only got natural cocoa on hand, use it but expect a brighter, slightly tangier bite.

Why the Water Bath Isn’t Optional

I know the water bath feels like an extra step. But I haven’t found a way around it when I want a clean, even bake.

The steam from the water helps regulate oven heat. It prevents the outer edge from setting too quickly, which keeps the top from cracking. Skip it, and your cheesecake may puff then deflate or worse, split across the top.

You can see this difference in texture when comparing baked cheesecakes with and without a bath. A water-bathed cake cuts smoother and holds up better on the plate.

Looking for another recipe that benefits from a precise bake? The Gingerbread Cheesecake Bars use a similar low-slow approach to keep their structure.

Chocolate Ganache That Slices Without Sliding

The ganache topping has one job—add shine, flavor, and contrast without overpowering.

I use a 2:1 cream-to-chocolate ratio here. That makes a slightly thinner ganache, one that spreads easily and firms just enough to cut. You won’t get a thick cap. Instead, the ganache becomes part of the bite.

Let it cool before pouring. If it’s too hot, it melts the top of your cheesecake and pulls at the surface. If it’s too cold, it sets before you can spread it.

Use a clean offset spatula and work from the center out.

Want a similar look in a no-bake format? My Peppermint Mocha Pudding Parfaits offer a softer version of this flavor profile, topped with whipped cream and crushed peppermint too.

Whipped Cream and Candy Topping That Holds Up

Whipped cream does more than decorate. It balances the richness of the filling. I use heavy cream and powdered sugar so the peaks stay firm.

You can pipe ahead, then chill the whole cheesecake for a few hours before serving. I top mine with crushed peppermint just before serving to keep the texture crisp.

I’ve also used mini candy canes or white chocolate curls when peppermint isn’t available. The key is contrast—soft cream, crunchy candy.

This isn’t a dessert that hides behind its garnish. It welcomes it.

Serving Notes That Matter: Slicing and Chilling

You’ll get the cleanest slices if the cheesecake is fully chilled, ideally overnight.

Use a hot knife wiped clean between each cut. I keep a tall glass of hot water nearby. This isn’t a step to rush. Each slice is part of the presentation.

Store leftovers in the fridge, covered. The peppermint flavor gets stronger over time, which some people love. After 2 days, the crust may soften, so plan to enjoy it within that window.

For those who like seasonal cheesecake ideas, Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownies strike a balance between richness and convenience.

---

Save This, Share This, and Come Back With Questions

I hope you’ll save this peppermint mocha cheesecake to your holiday baking board. This dessert rewards patience and attention to detail. It slices clean, serves beautifully, and makes people pause after that first bite.

Let me know in the comments how yours turned out. I read every note. If you changed something or served it a different way, share that too. This is a space for bakers to talk to each other.

And if you have questions mid-bake, drop them here. I’ll answer as best I can from my own kitchen.

---