Boston Cream Pie Cupcakes Recipe

There’s a reason these Boston Cream Pie Cupcakes keep showing up in my recipe notebooks. They’re soft in the center, neat in the hand, and rich without trying too hard. You’ll get a tender vanilla base, a cool custard core, and a pour of real ganache over the top. It’s a quiet showstopper. No bakery cases. No shortcuts. Just the kind of dessert that holds up at parties and disappears fast at home.

You’re going to learn how to make every part from scratch and that includes the pastry cream. I’ll guide you through it step by step. I’ve worked through the missteps already so you don’t have to.

Soft Vanilla Cupcakes with a Clean Crumb

I start with softened butter and cream it until light. The sugar goes in next, followed by eggs, one at a time. That part matters if you rush it, the texture tightens up later. The dry mix is straightforward: all-purpose flour, baking powder, and salt. Whole milk keeps the crumb tender and moist, without making it dense.

The key is to alternate the dry and wet additions. That helps the batter stay smooth. I divide it evenly into a lined tin and bake at 350°F. The tops should spring back slightly when pressed. I cool them on a wire rack. Don’t rush the cooling. Warm cupcakes resist the filling later.

If you’re curious about more flavor-forward cupcakes, try my Baileys Chocolate Cupcakes next. They lean into richness.

Making Smooth Pastry Cream from Scratch

This filling isn’t piped from a packet. It starts with hot milk and moves carefully through egg yolks, sugar, and cornstarch. I temper the eggs slowly with warm milk so they don’t curdle. Once it all comes back together in the pan, I whisk steadily over medium heat until the cream thickens to the texture of pudding.

It needs to boil briefly. That cooks out the starch. I remove it from the heat, add butter and vanilla, then chill it with plastic wrap directly on the surface. That keeps it smooth. Give it at least an hour in the fridge to firm up properly before you fill the cupcakes.

That same pastry cream technique works beautifully in Mini Boston Cream Pie Bites or even for a German Chocolate Cupcake base if you want to swap out coconut filling for custard.

Ganache that Shines and Sets Properly

I always use semi-sweet chocolate and heavy cream in equal proportion. I bring the cream to a simmer, then pour it over finely chopped chocolate. One minute of rest helps it melt. Then I stir until smooth. You can add a splash of corn syrup if you want extra gloss, but it holds well without it too.

Let it sit for 10 minutes. You want it fluid enough to pour but thick enough to stay put. If you spoon it too soon, it may run over the edge. I prefer a glossy cap with a clean edge. That way, each cupcake feels intentional, not messy.

If you’re more into nutty combinations, this method pairs well with the topping in my Chocolate Hazelnut Truffle Cupcakes too.

Why I Prefer Cornstarch over Flour in Pastry Cream

I’ve tested both. Flour makes the filling heavier and slightly duller in flavor. Cornstarch, on the other hand, thickens cleanly and keeps the custard light. You don’t taste the starch, and the cream sits better inside a cupcake without sinking the crumb.

In my notes, the cornstarch version holds its shape better when you bite through, especially if you plan to store them overnight.

Assembly Tips for a Clean Finish

Once the cupcakes are cool and the pastry cream is chilled, I cut small wells into each center. A paring knife works fine. I keep the tops if I want to cap them before ganache. That step is optional. Some people like the open custard look.

I spoon the filling in generously, but not so much it overflows. The ganache goes on last, right over the top. I let it settle naturally instead of spreading it. That gives a cleaner look and keeps fingerprints off the finish.

Store them chilled, but serve slightly closer to room temp. The textures open up that way. You can keep them up to 24 hours ahead, making them ideal for events or batch baking.

How to Serve and Store Like a Pro

I serve these on a plain white platter—no garnish needed. They stand on their own. If you’re making them for a birthday, try mixing in one or two no-frosting options for balance.

Leftovers go in a sealed container, chilled. The pastry cream stays safe for about three days, but texture is best in the first 24 to 36 hours. Don’t freeze them—the filling breaks down. If you need a freezer-friendly option, try Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes instead.

Save This for Later and Share Your Take

I’d love for you to pin this recipe so you can find it again. It’s the kind of dessert that’s worth repeating, especially when you want something polished that still feels like home baking.

Let me know in the comments how yours turned out. Did you cap the centers or leave them open? Any swaps you tried? I check in often and I love hearing your tweaks.

---