Sweet Potato Muffins With Pecan Streusel – Easy Fall Muffin Recipe

There’s something about a sweet potato muffin that brings more than just comfort. It brings memory. It tastes like a warm kitchen on a chilly morning, like something handed to you with care.

And this recipe, with its spiced crumb and golden-baked top, gives you that feeling without fuss. You’ll learn how to make moist sweet potato muffins topped with a buttery pecan oat streusel that stays crisp even after a day on the counter.

This is the kind of breakfast bake that holds its own against a slice of pound cake or a bakery cupcake. But it’s simpler. No mixer needed. No frosting, no glaze. Just the gentle sweetness of roasted sweet potatoes, wrapped in cinnamon warmth and finished with crunch.

You’ll leave here with confidence. These muffins won’t sink. They won’t dry out. And they’ll freeze better than most cupcakes I’ve tested.

I’ve made this sweet potato muffin recipe many times over the years, always tweaking and noting small things in my recipe book. What works. What doesn’t. This version is the one that stayed.

---

What Makes These Muffins Work So Well

The mashed sweet potato does most of the heavy lifting here. It adds moisture, subtle flavor, and a creamy texture that’s hard to beat.

You can use leftover roasted sweet potatoes, or boil them if that’s quicker. Roasting does deepen the flavor slightly, but both options will give you a soft, flavorful crumb.

You’ll also notice this batter uses both brown and white sugar. Brown sugar adds depth and helps the muffins retain moisture, while the white gives a touch of sweetness and a clean edge.

That balance matters. I’ve tried it with all brown sugar before, but the muffins leaned too far into molasses. A mix keeps it round and sweet without overshadowing the spices.

The topping matters, too. That pecan oat streusel doesn’t just sit on top for looks. It adds a nutty crunch and gives these muffins something extra especially if you’re planning to bring them to a brunch or give them as a seasonal gift.

One batch makes twelve, and they’re consistent. No sinking middles, no raw centers. Just a light dome and a crunchy top.

---

Ingredient Notes and Practical Tips

The flour is standard all-purpose, which holds up well against the moisture of the sweet potato. You won’t need cake flour here. If you’ve been storing your flour for a while, give it a good whisk before measuring to avoid dense muffins.

The oil keeps the crumb tender and helps the muffins stay fresh for longer. I’ve used melted butter in the past, but oil gives a lighter texture and extends shelf life. If you’re curious about swapping—stick with oil if you’re baking ahead or freezing.

The spice mix is warm and balanced. Cinnamon leads, supported by nutmeg and ginger. I sometimes skip the cloves, especially if I’m serving these to kids, since the flavor can come off strong. But for adults who love fall bakes, that pinch of clove rounds out the flavor.

If you’re looking for other ways to use sweet potatoes in baking, try my Sweet Potato Pie Recipe, which also leans on roasted sweet potatoes for body and flavor.

---

Baking Method and Streusel Comparison

After testing this recipe with both melted butter and solid butter in the streusel, I’ve settled on melted. It coats the oats better and creates a more cohesive crumble that clings to the muffin tops.

Cold butter cut in left too many dry pockets. And pecans? Don’t skip them. I’ve tried walnuts, but they don’t offer the same richness or crunch.

If you’re in the mood for something heartier, like a loaf, you might also enjoy the Cozy Sweet Potato Pound Cake—it carries similar flavor notes in a completely different format.

The muffins bake at 350°F, which gives enough time for the crumb to set while keeping the streusel from burning. Mine usually finish right at the 22-minute mark, but ovens vary. Use a toothpick to check the center—not the top. The streusel will look done before the middle is ready.

---

Serving Suggestions and Storage Advice

These muffins hold up beautifully at room temperature for two to three days. Store them in a container with a loose lid or leave a corner cracked open to preserve the crunchy top.

If you need longer storage, freeze them. They reheat best in a low oven. Avoid microwaving—they’ll go soft.

Serve warm with butter if you like, but they’re flavorful enough on their own. I’ve packed them into lunchboxes, wrapped them for road trips, and served them at breakfast buffets. They suit almost any moment.

For something with a chocolate twist, try the Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Muffins. That one plays a little sweeter, but the texture has a similar softness thanks to the pumpkin.

And if you’re leaning into fall flavors with cream cheese, the Pumpkin Cream Cheese Muffins are a nice step up in richness.

---

How These Muffins Fit Your Kitchen Routine

These work well for weekend baking or a quick weekday prep. You’ll need two bowls and a spatula. No mixer. You can mash the sweet potato the night before and keep it in the fridge. That saves time in the morning if you’re making them for breakfast.

They also fall into several handy categories Sweet Potato Breakfast Recipes, Sweet Potato Snacks, and even light Sweet Potato Dessert Recipes if you prefer something wholesome but still satisfying.

These aren’t cupcakes, but you could call them Sweet Potato Cupcakes if you crown them with a swirl of cream cheese frosting. I’ve done that once for a brunch table and watched them disappear before anything else.

---

Save This Recipe and Share Your Thoughts

If this Sweet Potato Muffin Recipe finds a spot in your baking routine, save it to your Sweet Potato Bread Recipe or Easy Muffins board on Pinterest. It’s one of those recipes you’ll want to come back to—especially in colder months or when you’ve got extra sweet potato to use up.

And let me know how yours turn out. Share in the comments if you made any changes or have questions. I always enjoy seeing how others bake through it, especially when the results end up slightly different. That’s part of the fun.

---